How to handle pooled samples

Although PHAROS is designed for granular (animal-level) data, pooled testing is still a welcome data source.

Researchers who are pooling samples from multiple animals can present that information one of two ways:

Option 1: One-to-many sample-animal relationship

Suppose a researcher swabs three marmosets, and pools the three swabs into a single test for herpesviruses---but still wants to record metadata on individual animals. They might represent the single positive test result as:

Sample ID Animal ID Host species Organism sex Detection outcome Pathogen GenBank accession
1 CApool1 Calla01 Callithrix aurita Female Positive Macacine alphaherpesvirus 1 GB8675309
2 CApool1 Calla002 Callithrix aurita Male Positive Macacine alphaherpesvirus 1 GB8675309
3 CApool1 Calla003 Callithrix aurita Female Positive Macacine alphaherpesvirus 1 GB8675309

In this format, the metadata for each animal is given on a separate row, but attached to the "Sample ID" and "GenBank accession".

Option 2: One-to-none sample-animal relationship

Suppose a researcher pools several dozen mosquitoes from a trap and tests that sample for West Nile virus.

Sample ID Animal ID Host species Detection outcome Pathogen GenBank accession Detection comments
Tuscon1 Aedes aegypti Positive West Nile virus GB1738 Pooled mosquito traps

In this format, individual animals are not identified, and the finest resolution of the data is at the trap (= sample) level.